Physics and engineering
Check units, derivations, model assumptions and whether proposed tests distinguish QFMT from established explanations.
Report a sighting INDEPENDENT REVIEW
Criticism belongs inside the method.
The project is establishing an external review network. No adviser or reviewer is presented as appointed, affiliated or endorsing the project without their explicit agreement.
APPOINTMENTSNone announced
ENDORSEMENTSNone implied
CONFLICTS REGISTERRequired before publication
OPEN REVIEWSMethods · data · QFMT
REVIEW PANELS
Six kinds of scrutiny.
Fame is not a substitute for relevant expertise. Review assignments will be scoped, documented and kept independent of publicity.
Statistics and data
Review selection effects, uncertainty, base rates, reproducibility and whether conclusions exceed the data.
Aviation and sensors
Test geometry, platform motion, sensor artefacts, flight operations, weather and ordinary aerospace causes.
Human factors
Review perception, memory, interview methods, trauma-aware practice and witness privacy.
Archives and law
Check provenance, record series, disclosure law, redactions, rights and public-interest claims.
Research integrity
Audit citations, versioning, corrections, conflicts and separation between evidence and hypothesis.
APPOINTMENT POLICY
Consent before naming.
Public researchers listed elsewhere on this site are directory subjects, not advisers. A reviewer will be named here only after accepting a defined scope, declaring relevant conflicts and agreeing that criticism or a negative conclusion may be published accurately.
Minimum disclosure
- Expertise and institutional affiliation
- Financial, advocacy and personal conflicts
- Material reviewed and date completed
- Whether comments were advisory or a formal review
- Unresolved disagreements and author response
NOMINATE OR APPLY
Contact the review desk →Help test the work.
Independent specialists can volunteer for a defined review. Please include your field, relevant experience, conflicts and the material you want to examine.